On March 13, 2014 at 3:47PM, police were called to the Dollar General Store located at 1077 S. Edgar Street for a retail theft in progress. As a result of the on-scene investigation, Ritter was arrested for Retail Theft (F3). Ms Ritter was taken to York County Central Booking for processing and was later released on R.O.R. bail.
A second suspect, Nichole C. Kirkland, age 43, of York, PA, was also arrested and charged with Retail Theft (M2).